Jump to content
  • Sign Up
×
×
  • Create New...
New feature: 1 Vote = 0.10€ for server Owner!

Why the 1924 Democratic National Convention Was the Longest and Most Chaotic of Its Kind in U.S. History

Pelican Press

By Pelican Press,
in World News

 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Diamond Member
Pelican Press Warlord

Pelican Press 0

Posted
  • Diamond Member
Posted



Why the 1924 Democratic National Convention Was the Longest and Most Chaotic of Its Kind in U.S. History

“I belong to no organized party,” the humorist Will Rogers

This is the hidden content, please
in 1924. “I’m a Democrat.”

Rogers had just witnessed the longest and by some accounts “

This is the hidden content, please
” political convention in ********* history: the 1924 Democratic National Convention, which took 16 days and 103 ballots to nominate a presidential candidate.

Beginning on June 24, the summer convention was a bleak, sweltering affair for the Democrats. Initially buoyed by optimism over

This is the hidden content, please
within incumbent President Calvin Coolidge’s *********** Party, the Democrats quickly became aware that their coalition was even more divided. Dueling factions representing starkly different constituencies, policies and worldviews had come together in New York City’s Madison Square Garden to tear each other apart with no plans for reconciliation or compromise.

William G. McAdoo served as a lawyer in Tennessee, a tunnel-building businessman in New York City and secretary of the Treasury in Woodrow Wilson’s cabinet. He quietly courted the ****’s support.

This is the hidden content, please

Governor Al Smith of New York was from an Irish ********* family on the Lower East Side of Manhattan. Members of the **** destroyed his effigy during the convention.

This is the hidden content, please

The divisions within the party were so profound that fights broke out on the convention floor and across the New York metropolitan area. At one point,

This is the hidden content, please
of the Ku Klux Klan, which backed leading candidate
This is the hidden content, please
, “battered to a shapeless pulp” an effigy of New York Governor
This is the hidden content, please
, the other front-runner, at a demonstration across the Hudson River in New Jersey, wrote historian
This is the hidden content, please
in
This is the hidden content, please
.

By the final ballot on July 9, delegates had abandoned their first-, second- and 102nd-choice candidates and settled on

This is the hidden content, please
of West Virginia, a
This is the hidden content, please
, congressman and compromise candidate who satisfied almost no one.

After all the chaos of the convention, the Democrats lost badly to Coolidge in the 1924 presidential

This is the hidden content, please
. The Republicans’
This is the hidden content, please
, “Coolidge or chaos,” resounded across the country, reminding voters of the troubled state of the Democratic Party. Davis won just 12 states—all of the former Confederate states plus Oklahoma—and
This is the hidden content, please
of the popular vote.

Because of its disorganization and ultimate ********, the 1924 DNC has been largely forgotten. But its flaws—as well as the glimmers of hope that squeaked out of Madison Square Garden—offer valuable lessons 100 years later, as a new generation of Democrats prepares to nominate President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris for re-election

This is the hidden content, please
this August.

A party divided against itself

Ahead of the 1924 convention, the Democratic Party was in the throes of an identity crisis.

Since its founding in 1828, the

This is the hidden content, please
had been committed to an
This is the hidden content, please
of ********* democracy, rooted firmly in land ownership, limited government and ************* social policy. Through the Civil War, the Democrats contrasted themselves
This is the hidden content, please
, the party of Abraham Lincoln and
This is the hidden content, please
. By 1932, however, these positions had started to shift, with Democrats dominated by Franklin D. Roosevelt’s
This is the hidden content, please
coalition supporting an expanded federal government and socially progressive policies that are more in line with the party’s platform today.

The 1924 DNC caught the party in an awkward spot, with a progressive wing slowly differentiating itself from the old guard in light of socioeconomic transformations unfolding across the country. “The old local, or even regional, economy was giving up ground to a national economy,” says

This is the hidden content, please
, a sociologist at the University of Notre Dame. Small-scale producers in rural areas faced increasing competition with large-scale capitalism in major cities.

Waves of immigration from Central and Eastern Europe also upset the interwar social order, leaving white Protestants across the country in “deep pockets of discontent,” McVeigh adds.

Those who felt left behind, replaced or threatened were susceptible to manipulation by the

This is the hidden content, please
, which underwent a
This is the hidden content, please
, in part because of its ability to prey on middle-class economic fears, misplaced patriotism and overt bigotry.

On the other hand, more progressive Democrats in the Northeast ******* States were “trying to appeal to this growing working-class immigrant population,” McVeigh says.

In place of its once-unified agrarian base, the Democratic Party was now profoundly divided.

In his first public appearance after contracting polio, Franklin D. Roosevelt campaigned for Al Smith and dubbed him “the happy warrior.”

This is the hidden content, please

The unapparent heirs

The three major candidates for the Democratic nomination “epitomized the party’s urban-rural, religious and sectional divisions,”

This is the hidden content, please
historian
This is the hidden content, please
in
This is the hidden content, please
.

This is the hidden content, please
was the leading candidate for much of the lead-up to the convention. Born in Georgia in 1863, McAdoo had
This is the hidden content, please
as a lawyer in Tennessee, a tunnel-building businessman in New York City and secretary of the Treasury in Democrat Woodrow Wilson’s cabinet. After the ****** of his first wife, McAdoo
This is the hidden content, please
This is the hidden content, please
, the president’s daughter, in 1914. McAdoo’s friends and political allies from his time in the cabinet pushed him to become Wilson’s
This is the hidden content, please
in the 1920 election, but he refused the mantle and
This is the hidden content, please
to avoid hostile East Coast politics.

The Democratic Party’s success in the

This is the hidden content, please
encouraged McAdoo to return to politics and announce his candidacy. Soon enough, the
This is the hidden content, please
reported that the Democratic race was “rapidly developing into a McAdoo and anti-McAdoo affair.”

McAdoo’s base was concentrated in the rural South and West, where the politician quietly courted the support of the ****, which was waging a moral war in favor of Prohibition and continuing its *********** white supremacist crusade.

Leading the anti-McAdoo contingent was Smith, the governor of New York. He set himself up against the ****, a group that was existentially opposed to this descendent of Irish ********* immigrants and the diversifying, urban Northeast he represented.

“Smith was the thing that people would hold out … to scare native-born white Protestants who flocked to the Ku Klux Klan,” McVeigh says.

Between these worldviews, little common ground existed. But pockets of nuance existed.

The third front-runner entering the convention was

This is the hidden content, please
, a senator from Alabama. A Southerner through and through, as well as a loud opponent of the ****, Underwood drew impressive support from his home state, with one local paper
This is the hidden content, please
“democracy’s safeguard.” But his nuanced position ******* to capture the restive mood within the party or dissuade delegates from backing other local nominees.

As

This is the hidden content, please
, a communications scholar at Furman University, wrote in a 2020
This is the hidden content, please
, “Every state wanted its man on the top of the ticket, and the bosses were ready to lock horns.”

Democratic convention in New York City 1924

The “Klanbake” begins

The New York

This is the hidden content, please
reported that on June 24, the first day of the convention, the “Klanbake steamed open at 12:45.”

The party was “irreconcilably divided over the Klan issue,” McVeigh says. Whether to condemn the **** by name was the most pressing issue that the Democratic Party had to confront before it could make any real progress.

A majority of the committee members who were tasked with drafting the party’s religious freedom platform (including ******* presidential candidate William Jennings Bryan, who

This is the hidden content, please
the party turn to ****** and ignore the **** issue outright) did not want to condemn the hate group by name.
This is the hidden content, please
only vaguely stated how the party would “deplore and condemn any effort to arouse religious or ******* dissension.”

A

This is the hidden content, please
, meanwhile, pledged “to oppose any effort on the part of the Ku Klux Klan or any organization to interfere with the religious liberty or political freedom of any citizen … or to limit the civic rights of any citizen or body of citizens because of religion, birthplace or ******* origin.”

Support for the two planks was mostly cast along regional lines. Delegates from Southern and Western states—those who would later back McAdoo—favored the Klan-sympathetic platform. Northern, pro-Smith delegates tended toward the alternative option.

Senator Oscar W. Underwood of Alabama came from an elite Southern family. He rejected the **** but ******* to gain traction at the convention.

This is the hidden content, please

John W. Davis, the Democratic nominee, was a low-profile congressman from West Virginia. Many in his own party opposed his close ties to big business.

This is the hidden content, please

Andrew Cobb Erwin, a delegate from Georgia, was one of the few who “spoke outside the stereotype of a Southern politician and against the ****,” wrote Lewis.

In an interview, Lewis explains how much of a political rarity Erwin was. He descended from “the gentry class in Virginia,” she says. “He was a longstanding aristocratic Southern gentleman.” His father was the first recipient of the Confederate Cross of Honor, and his enslaver ancestors had

This is the hidden content, please
in Athens, Georgia, named in their honor.

Despite his pedigree, Erwin

This is the hidden content, please
the crowd of delegates at the convention that he would “favor a plank denouncing [the ****], or any other secret society, in as strong words as a human hand can write.”

“You can, by adopting the report of the majority, evade the issue, which would, in effect, give your approval to the activities of this organization,” he said. “Follow this course, and you may prepare for an ignominious defeat at the polls in November.”

Erwin added, “Meet the issue squarely, as the people of this country expect you to meet it, and a glorious victory will be yours.”

The reaction was mixed—a cacophony of jeers, hisses and applause. Many Southerners turned their back on Erwin. But New York’s delegates lifted him up and paraded him around Madison Square Garden. A woman from Rhode Island ran up to Erwin and kissed him on the mouth.

The convention ultimately adopted the

This is the hidden content, please
and ******* to condemn the **** by name. The pro-McAdoo Democrats had made their position clear, widening the rift within the party. “That’s where the convention turned,” Lewis says. As for Erwin, his prediction of political ***** in November would soon prove all too prescient.

Democratic delegates like Thomas J. Walsh of Montana converged on Madison Square Garden to choose their next presidential nominee. Chaos and division ensued.

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division

The convention gave women like Georgia English more opportunities than ever before to wade into the muck of party politics as advisers, as delegates and even as potential candidates.

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division

“Women in star roles”

Despite the Democrats’ regressive stance on the ****, the party still showed signs of social progress.

Together with the 1924 *********** National Convention, where women “ruled the floor,” according to historian

This is the hidden content, please
, the DNC gave women more opportunities than ever before to wade into the muck of party politics. Daily News reporter Imogene Stanley
This is the hidden content, please
that women made up “almost half the milling crowd in the Garden,” with some “in star roles,” including 54 members of the party’s national committee.

The 1924 DNC marked the

This is the hidden content, please
a women was nominated for vice president at a major party’s political convention.
This is the hidden content, please
, a women’s rights activist from South Carolina, won 44 votes, while two other women received at least one vote each. Ultimately, none was successful.

Behind the scenes, Smith’s closest adviser,

This is the hidden content, please
, was “the nearest thing to a woman political boss in the ******* States,”
This is the hidden content, please
journalist Josephine van de Grift. “At Albany, they openly call her the ‘prime minister of New York State.’”

In her

This is the hidden content, please
of Moskowitz, historian Elisabeth Israels Perry
This is the hidden content, please
that the adviser “was in the thick of the 1924 contest.” She was by Smith’s side throughout the convention, where she “churned out publicity and handled all correspondence on Smith’s candidacy.”

Speaking with van de Grift in 1924, Moskowitz said, “Women in politics can achieve more behind the scenes than in office.” She added, “I’m more interested in policies than politics.” But the chaos that followed was pure, messy politics, and the subtleties of policy differences were all but left behind.

The New York Daily News announced McAdoo’s arrival in New York, likening the upcoming convention to a “battlefield.”

This is the hidden content, please

“An idiotic and depressing spectacle”

Even before voting began, partisan tensions among the Democrats stretched into every part of the convention’s pomp and circumstance.

The great ********* songwriter Irving Berlin was commissioned to write a keynote song for the convention that one organizer

This is the hidden content, please
would be “as important as the keynote speech.” But Berlin’s song ultimately became a pro-Smith ditty
This is the hidden content, please
“We’ll All Go Voting for Al”—not exactly an anthem of party unity.

In Madison Square Garden, rival factions started chanting. “Mac, Mac, McAdoo” was quickly answered by “Smith, Smith, Alfred Smith” and “Ku, Ku, McAdoo.” Physical

This is the hidden content, please
broke out on the floor. The unrest didn’t bode well for either McAdoo or Smith, who would have to take two-thirds of the delegates—732 votes—to secure the nomination.

On the first ballot, McAdoo took 431.5 votes, and Smith took 241, for a combined 61 percent of the total votes. Underwood, the anti-**** senator from Alabama, won 42.5 delegates. Other votes were spread among 16 candidates, who received between 1 and 59 votes each.

Across dozens more ballots, state delegations kept voting for their “favorite sons,” like

This is the hidden content, please
, the governor of Maryland, who consistently hovered around 17.5 votes—an insignificant 1.6 percent of the delegates.

As journalist H.L. Mencken wrote in a column for the Baltimore

This is the hidden content, please
, “The delegates kept on voting for their pets as before, like children poll-parroting a meaningless rhyme. It was an idiotic and depressing spectacle.”

He continued, “If you can imagine 3,000 dogs in one great pit, all frantically chasing their tails, you can imagine what it looked like.”

Will Rogers found much

This is the hidden content, please
in the convention’s length, which far surpassed the
This is the hidden content, please
of 46 ballots needed to nominate Wilson in 1912. He told readers in gleeful detail about the piles of whittling carvings that the Arkansas delegation had made, as well as the ever-growing whiskers of one bearded Utah delegate.

But there were kernels of truth in his pages of jest. “Pick [a nominee] now,” he implored. “In fact, I would pick out three or four to run in rotation in 1928, ’32, ’36 and so on, because you will never get Democratic delegates to give up the best part of their lives by attending another one of these things.” (As if to highlight the growing absurdity and deterioration of the convention—or perhaps in agreement with Rogers’ commentary—Arizona’s delegation cast a

This is the hidden content, please
for the humorist on the 67th ballot.)

Partisan tensions reached every part of the convention’s pomp and circumstance. Even anthems of party unity were turned into one-sided ditties.

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division

Little by little, favorite sons

This is the hidden content, please
dropped out. McAdoo and Smith maneuvered furiously for votes, but neither could reach the two-thirds majority, and by the 99th ballot, neither saw a path to victory. The two candidates simultaneously told their supporters to
This is the hidden content, please
, but neither formally withdrew, waiting for the other to fold first. Some stuck with McAdoo or Smith for a few more votes before dwindling off. The stalemate was coming to a close.

Davis, who had been quietly trailing the two front-runners for most of the convention, often in a distant third place, emerged as the leading contender, and over the next several ballots—until the infamous 103rd—“state after state fell in line until … he had a majority,” according to the

This is the hidden content, please
.

In the wee hours of July 10, in a surprisingly efficient turn of events, the Democrats gave

This is the hidden content, please
, governor of Nebraska and brother of William Jennings Bryan, the vice presidential
This is the hidden content, please
in a single ballot.

The

This is the hidden content, please
noted that Davis “had never met his running mate … until the opening of the convention.” The two men, the paper reported, “are direct opposites. Almost as much unalike as McAdoo and Smith, but in a different way.”

These revelations did little to inspire party unity or confidence about the nominees.

“Chaos or Coolidge” and how the Democrats lost the 1924 election

Though Davis was a compromise candidate, his nomination did little to patch up the party’s wounds, and neither side was particularly pleased with the outcome.

McAdoo blamed

This is the hidden content, please
and its “obstructionist tactics” for his loss, wrote Lee N. Allen in a 1963
This is the hidden content, please
. Smith was convinced the **** and his own Catholicism cost him the nomination: He “never received more than a single vote from the South” across the 103 ballots, according to Murray.

By the time Davis secured the nomination, Madison Square Garden, once the sweltering site of intense, at times violent enthusiasm, was all but abandoned.

Both fundamentalist Democrats like

This is the hidden content, please
and ******** Democrats were
This is the hidden content, please
of Davis’ close ties to Wall Street from his time as a corporate lawyer. To counter what he saw as a false choice between two conservatives, Senator
This is the hidden content, please
of Wisconsin ran independently as a progressive, socialist candidate in the general election.

The press was not too impressed with Davis, either. The

This is the hidden content, please
ran a humiliating article about how “Davis as a boy was afraid of ******.” The Democratic nominee for president was alleged to have “no plans for the immediate future, other than to obtain a needed rest.”

After 103 ballots and 16 days, the convention was over. One reporter called it “an idiotic and depressing spectacle.”

Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division

On a national scale, the internal strife within the party, its raucous convention and its tacit support of the **** scuttled the Democrats’ hopes of electoral success.

“This was certainly an embarrassment because it was the first convention that was broadcast on radio,” Lewis says. “So people could tune in and hear all of the folderol.”

As the

This is the hidden content, please
predicted, “The Democratic Convention of 1924 registered chaos so long that even the benign and dignified figure of Mr. Davis will hardly assuage the doubts of the voters.”

Coolidge, running as a stable, time-tested leader, cruised to re-election, winning 54 percent of the popular vote in the three-way race against Davis and La Follette.

“They got what they deserve,” Lewis says of the Democrats’ defeat. “That’s a terrible thing to say, yes. [But] they created this conflict, and they chose poorly.”

The legacy of the 1924 Democratic National Convention

One hundred years after the Democrats came together in Madison Square Garden and nominated Davis, the 1924 DNC still casts a long shadow. It was a convention of extremes—the longest, the

This is the hidden content, please
on the radio—but it also came at a moment of deep internal strife for both the party and the nation.

In McVeigh’s view, the ****’s malign influence, as well as the Democrats’ subsequent loss in the election, was responsible for the “acceleration of realignment in the parties that was already taking place,” paving the way for Smith’s eventual nomination in 1928 and Roosevelt’s New Deal coalition in 1932. (Smith lost to Herbert Hoover in the 1928

This is the hidden content, please
, carrying just
This is the hidden content, please
.)

1924 marked the

This is the hidden content, please
a ****** delegate attended the DNC. A.P. Collins, an alternate from New York, replaced a white delegate who dropped out. In 1928, however, no ****** delegates participated in the convention.

Lena Springs, a women’s rights activist from Tennessee, was the first woman nominated for vice president at a major political party’s convention. She won 44 votes at the 1924 DNC.

This is the hidden content, please

Geraldine Ferraro was the first woman to win the vice presidential nomination. She ran alongside Walter Mondale in 1984.

This is the hidden content, please

Similarly, although the 1924 DNC marked the first time that women were put up for the vice presidential nomination, a woman didn’t secure the candidacy until 1984, when Democrat Geraldine Ferraro ran alongside Walter Mondale.

Reflecting on the 1924 convention’s legacy, Lewis finds hope in its examples of resistance, like Erwin, who spoke up against the ****. She tells the story of Erwin’s grandson, a

This is the hidden content, please
named Milton Leathers, who
This is the hidden content, please
his grandfather’s speech during a 2017 town meeting about removing a Confederate monument in Georgia.

In Erwin’s words, carried into the 21st century by his proud family and by dedicated scholars like Lewis, “I say that those Georgians who do not take a stand against this hooded menace, which prowls in the darkness, that dares not show its face, is not worthy of his ancestry; and I call upon you, my fellow Georgians, … to purge from your hearts this senseless prejudice.”

Get the latest History stories in your inbox?







This is the hidden content, please

******** ********* History, ********* History, ********* Presidents, ********* ******** History Initiative, Calvin Coolidge, Democracy, Elections, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, History of Now, Immigrants, New York City, Political Leaders, Politics, Racism, ******** History, Woodrow Wilson
#Democratic #National #Convention #Longest #Chaotic #Kind #U.S #History

This is the hidden content, please

For verified travel tips and real support, visit: https://hopzone.eu/
0

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Vote for the server

    To vote for this server you must login.

    Jim Carrey Flirting GIF

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

Privacy Notice: We utilize cookies to optimize your browsing experience and analyze website traffic. By consenting, you acknowledge and agree to our Cookie Policy, ensuring your privacy preferences are respected.

  I accept