What does China’s ‘magic weapon’ of influence do?

[Pelican Press 0]

This is the hidden content, please

• Sign In
• or
• Sign Up

What does China’s ‘magic weapon’ of influence do?

Getty Images

China’s United Front Work Department is an arm of the ********** Party

The People’s Republic of China has a “magic weapon”, according to its founding leader Mao Zedong and its current president Xi Jinping.

It is called the United Front Work Department – and it is raising as much alarm in the West as Beijing’s growing military arsenal.

Yang Tengbo, a prominent businessman who has been linked to Prince Andrew, is the latest overseas ******** citizen to be scrutinised – and sanctioned – for his links to the UFWD.

The existence of the department is far from a secret. A decades-old and well-documented arm of the ******** ********** Party, it has been mired in controversy before. Investigators from the US to Australia have cited the UFWD in multiple espionage cases, often accusing Beijing of using it for foriegn interference.

Beijing has denied all espionage allegations, calling them ludicrous.

So what is the UFWD and what does it do?

‘Controlling China’s message’

The United Front – originally referring to a broad ********** alliance – was once hailed by Mao as the key to the ********** Party’s triumph in the decades-long ******** Civil War.

After the war ended in 1949 and the party began ruling China, United Front activities took a ********* to other priorities. But in the last decade under Xi, the United Front has seen a renaissance of sorts.

Xi’s version of the United Front is broadly consistent with earlier incarnations: to “build the broadest possible coalition with all social forces that are relevant”, according to Mareike Ohlberg, a senior fellow at the ******* Marshall Fund.

On the face of it, the UFWD is not shadowy – it even has a website and reports many of its activities on it. But the extent of its work – and its reach – is less clear.

While a large part of that work is domestic, Dr Ohlberg said, “a key target that has been defined for United Front work is overseas ********”.

Today, the UFWD seeks to influence public discussions about sensitive issues ranging from Taiwan – which China claims as its territory – to the suppression of ethnic minorities in Tibet and Xinjiang.

It also tries to shape narratives about China in foreign media, target ******** government critics abroad and co-opt influential overseas ******** figures.

“United Front work can include espionage but [it] is broader than espionage,” Audrye Wong, assistant professor of politics at the University of Southern California, tells the BBC.

“Beyond the act of acquiring covert information from a foreign government, United Front activities centre on the broader mobilisation of overseas ********,” she said, adding that China is “unique in the scale and scope” of such influence activities.

Reuters

Xi Jinping has pushed for an assertive China abroad

China has always had the ambition for such influence, but it’s rise in recent decades has given Beijing the ability to exercise it.

Since Xi became president in 2012, he has been especially proactive in crafting China’s message to the world, enouraging a confrontational “wolf warrior” approach to diplomacy and urging his country’s diaspora to “tell China’s story well”.

The UFWD operates through various overseas ******** community organisations, which have vigorously defended the ********** Party beyond its shores. They have censored anti-CCP artwork and protested at the activities of Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama. The UFWD has also been linked to threats against members of persecuted minorities abroad, such as Tibetans and Uyghurs.

But much of the UFWD’s work overlaps with other party agencies, operating under what observers have described as “plausible deniability”.

It is this murkiness that is causing so much suspicion and apprehension about the UFWD.

When Yang appealed against his ban from the *** amid espionage allegations, an immigration court ruled that he had downplayed his ties with the UFWD. *** officials allege he leveraged his relationships with influential British figures for ******** state interference.

Yang, however, maintains that he has not done anything unlawful and that the spy allegations are “entirely untrue”.

Supplied

Mr Yang seen here with Prince Andrew

Cases like Yang’s are becoming increasingly common. In 2022, British ******** lawyer Christine Lee was accused by the MI5 of acting through the UFWD to cultivate relationships with influential people in the ***. The following year, Liang Litang, a US citizen who ran a ******** restaurant in Boston, was indicted for providing information about ******** dissidents in the area to his contacts in the UFWD.

And in September, Linda Sun, a former aide in the New York governor’s office, was charged with using her position to serve ******** government interests – receiving benefits, including travel, in return. According to ******** state media reports, she had met a top UFWD official in 2017, who told her to “be an ambassador of Sino-American friendship”.

It is not uncommon for prominent and successful ******** people to be associated with the party, whose approval they often need, especially in the business world.

But where is the line between peddling influence and espionage?

“The boundary between influence and espionage is blurry” when it comes to Beijing’s operations, said Ho-fung Hung, a politics professor at Johns Hopkins University.

This ambiguity has intensified after China passed a law in 2017 mandating ******** nationals and companies to co-operate with intelligence probes, including sharing information with the ******** government – a move that Dr Hung said “effectively turns everyone into potential spies”.

The Ministry of State Security has released dramatic propaganda videos warning the public that foreign spies are everywhere and “they are cunning and sneaky “.

Some students who were sent on special trips abroad were told by their universities to limit contact with foreigners and were asked for a report of their activities on their return.

And yet Xi is keen to promote China to the world. So he has tasked a trusted arm of the party to project strength abroad.

And that is becoming a challenge for Western powers – how do they balance doing business with the world’s second-largest economy alongside serious security concerns?

Wrestling with the long arm of Beijing

Genuine fears over China’s overseas influence are playing into more hawkish sentiments in the West, often leaving governments in a dilemma.

This is the hidden content, please

• Sign In
• or
• Sign Up

that criminalise individuals deemed to be meddling in domestic affairs. In 2020, the US imposed visa restrictions on people seen as active in UFWD activities.

An irked Beijing has warned that such laws – and the prosecutions they have spurred – hinder bilateral relations.

“The so-called allegations of ******** espionage are utterly absurd,” a foreign ministry spokesperson told reporters on Tuesday in response to a question about Yang. “The development of China-*** relations serves the common interests of both countries.”

Some experts say that the long arm of China’s United Front is indeed concerning.

“Western governments now need to be less naive about China’s United Front work and take it as a serious threat not only to national security but also to the safety and freedom of many ethnic ******** citizens,” Dr Hung says.

But, he adds, “governments also need to be vigilant against anti-******** racism and work hard to build trust and co-operation with ethnic ******** communities in countering the threat together.”

Getty Images

The UFWD has been accused of pressuring overseas dissidents and critics of the ********** Party

Last December, Di Sanh Duong, a Vietnam-born ethnic ******** community leader in Australia, was convicted of planning foreign interference for trying to cosy up to an *********** minister. Prosecutors argued that he was an “ideal target” for the UFWD because he had run for office in the 1990s and boasted ties with ******** officials.

Duong’s trial had centred around what he meant when he said the inclusion of the minister at a charity event would be beneficial to “us ********” – did he mean the ******** community in Australia, or mainland China?

In the end, Duong’s conviction – and a prison sentence – raised serious concerns that such broad anti-espionage laws and prosecutions can easily become

This is the hidden content, please

• Sign In
• or
• Sign Up

“It’s important to remember that not everyone who is ethnically ******** is a supporter of the ******** ********** Party. And not everyone who is involved in these diaspora organisations is driven by fervent loyalty to China,” Dr Wong says.

“Overly aggressive policies based on racial profiling will only legitimise the ******** government’s propaganda that ethnic ******** are not welcome and end up pushing diaspora communities further into Beijing’s arms.”

This is the hidden content, please

• Sign In
• or
• Sign Up

#Chinas #magic #weapon #influence

This is the hidden content, please

• Sign In
• or
• Sign Up

This is the hidden content, please

• Sign In
• or
• Sign Up